-
(#9) Harry Should Have Died In The Chamber Of Secrets
From Redditor u/Mr_doodlebop:
Basilisk venom destroys Horcruxes right? Like, INSTANTLY. When every Horcrux was hit with the sword of Gryffindor (which absorbed the power of basilisk venom) the Horcrux like exploded and was gone, and when Nagini was cut by the sword she disintegrated. So how come in the Chamber of Secrets when Harry is bit by the basilisk he was okay? He didn't explode, no black spirit came out of him, he didn't disentigrate. Then five books later we come to find that there is still a Horcrux inside of him. so... WTF?
-
(#3) Practicing Magic Outside Hogwarts
From Redditor u/leashkid:
So the Ministry of Magic keeps insisting that students cannot use magic out of school and yet at the start of the third movie Harry learns Lumos Maxima under his bed covers. How is he allowed to do that? I mean he almost gets expelled because Dobby levitated pudding in the second book...
-
(#1) An Easily Breakable Lock
From Redditor u/Chgr:
In the first movie, on the very beginning when Harry and Hermione are Hogwarts students just for a few weeks, they roam through Hogwarts, they come to the door behind which there is something valuable as they believe. But then, Harry sadly notices that the door is locked. So then a Hermione does a spell, "Alohamora," and unlocks it. Why in the Earth would anyone, especially wise wizards leave anything valuable behind locked door as a security when anybody, even those who are students there just for few weeks, can just do freaking Alohamora?
-
(#13) Do Dentists Exist Or Not?
From Redditor u/smoovenutz:
In Chamber of Secrets, right when the boys get back to the Burrow from rescuing Harry at the Dursleys, the camera pans to the clock that shows where the Weasley's are (work, home, school, etc). I noticed that one of the places where they could be was the dentist. In the Half Blood Prince, when Hermione explains to Slughorn and the rest of the Slug Club what her parents do for a living (her father is a dentist) they all seem confused as to what that is because I'm assuming wizards don't visit the dentist or maybe it is just because they are British. I'm not sure, but it seems like a a continuity error/plothole I'd point out.
-
(#17) Horcrux Invulnerability
From Redditor u/WamsyTheOneAndOnly:
The only other living Horcrux is Nagini, in [Nagini's death scene] in the Deathly Hallows, Ron tries to cast a spell on Nagini and hits, but it bounces off and does nothing. In The Chamber of Secrets however when Harry and Malfoy are bought on stage to duel Malfoy sends Harry to the other side of the stage. Since they are both living and are both Horcruxes, the spells should affect them both the same.
I've never read the books and I don't know very much about Harry Potter so excuse me if there's a reason to this.
New Random Displays Display All By Ranking
About This Tool
Our data comes from Ranker, If you want to participate in the ranking of items displayed on this page, please click here.